| Year Awarded | Recipient(s) | Sport |
| 2018 | Lesli Akeo '13 | Volleyball |
| Bryan Neufeld '13 | Men's Lacrosse | |
| Brittany Pavolko '11 | Swimming & Diving | |
| 2017 | Ashleigh (Barone) Bonzerato '12 | Women's Soccer |
| Brent Herbst '11 | Men's Lacrosse | |
| Fran McCaffery | Men's Basketball (Coach) | |
| Ronald Moore '12 | Men's Basketball | |
| 2016 | Nadiege Honore '08 | Volleyball |
| Ryan Rossiter '11 | Basketball | |
| Tabitha Tice '11 | Women's Soccer | |
| Chris Viviano '09 | Men's Lacrosse | |
| 2015 | Dave Pahucki '02 | Baseball |
| Christie (Gustafson) Ryan '07 | Volleyball | |
| Alex Franklin '10 | Men's Basketball | |
| Burgandy-Leigh McCurty '10 | Volleyball | |
| 2014 | Chris Alesio '89 | Baseball |
| April London '09 | Volleball | |
| Sarah Mayer '09 | Women's Tennis | |
| Kenny Hasbrouck '09 | Men's Basketball | |
| 2013 | Tim Holloway '91 | Football |
| Laura (Menty) Menges '08 | Women's Basketball | |
| 2012 | Bryan J. Bigley '07 | Men's Golf |
| Kelly M. Morrissey '03 | Women's Swimming | |
| Mike Deane | Men's Basketball (Coach) | |
| 2011 | Dwayne A. Archbold '02 | Men's Basketball |
| Gunta Basko '03 | Women's Basketball | |
| Robert D. Bigley '06 | Men's Golf | |
| Noel Cox '06 | Women's Soccer | |
| Liene Jansone '04 | Women's Basketball | |
| John E. Lannan '06 | Baseball | |
| Nicole M. Mayer '03 | Women's Tennis | |
| Katherine S. Sturgis '83 | Women's Basketball | |
| Henry J. Wysocki, Jr. | Volleyball (Coach) | |
| 2010 | Donna DeFrancesco '97 | Volleyball/Softball |
| Todd W. Donovan '03 | Baseball | |
| Marcus V. Faison '00 | Men's Basketball | |
| Ryan M. Finn '02 | Baseball | |
| 2009 | ||
| 2008 | ||
| 2007 | ||
| 2006 | Kristen M. May '97 | Volleyball |
| 2005 | Melanie S. Halker '99 | Women's Basketball |
| 2004 | Timothy A. Christman '98 | Baseball |
| Reginald L. Greene '98 | Football | |
| 2003 | Kimberly J. Colunio '95 | Women's Basketball |
| Paul J. Wilders '96 | Baseball | |
| 2002 | Paul D. Laniewski '88 | Men’s Soccer |
| Rochelle D. Travers '96 | Volleyball | |
| 2001 | Bruce A. Schroeder '92 | Basketball |
| 2000 | Elizabeth J. Lops '94 | Basketball |
| Robert Hutchinson '83 | Lacrosse | |
| 1999 | Lee K. Matthews '93 | Basketball |
| Craig D. Turnbull '87 | Baseball | |
| Angela C. Fedullo '83 | Basketball/Softball | |
| 1998 | Valerie S. Higgins '91 | Basketball |
| Mark J. Jenkins '82 | Lacrosse | |
| Marc Brown '91 | Basketball | |
| 1997 | ||
| 1996 | Jeffrey O. Robinson '90 | Basketball |
| Russell Ferris | Lacrosse (Coach) | |
| 1995 | ||
| 1994 | Khris C. Clemens '84 | Baseball |
| Ann Marie Graney '85 | Basketball | |
| Stephen G. McCoy '89 | Basketball | |
| 1993 | Richard H. Coughlin '82 | Cross Country |
| Eric W. Banks '86 | Basketball | |
| Matthew Brady '87 | Basketball | |
| 1992 | Thomas J. Baldwin, Jr. '81 | Lacrosse |
| Catherine F. Rosseau '82 | Basketball | |
| 1991 | Robert E. Bladel '80 | Baseball |
| Heidi A. Harkins '84 | Basketball | |
| Kenneth H. Hayner '82 | Baseball | |
| James P. Howard '84 | Baseball | |
| 1990 | Francis X. Bice ‘82 | Football/Lacrosse |
| Jane M. Buratto ‘82 | Field Hockey | |
| Douglas Poetzsch ‘85 | Basketball | |
| 1989 | Daniel J. Cahill ‘75 | Basketball |
| Joseph M. Hogan ’67 | Women's Basketball (Coach) | |
| Richard A. Smith '75 | Basketball | |
| Charles P. Taaffe '73 | Football | |
| 1988 | Mary E. Gaudreau '83 | Basketball |
| Kevin M. McGraw '82 | Basketball | |
| Robert P. Reilly | Cross Country (Coach) | |
| Michael C. Schongar '71 | Football | |
| 1987 | Victoria Aromando '82 | Basketball |
| Jack Callahan '72 | Golf | |
| David B. Smith '79 | Baseball | |
| 1986 | Anthony S. Asterino '81 | Lacrosse |
| Stephen P. O'Shea '79 | Lacrosse | |
| Anthony L. Rossi | Baseball (Coach) | |
| 1985 | Michael E. Catino '81 | Basketball |
| Thomas J. Dalton '80 | Cross Country | |
| Michael J. Seymour '70 | Basketball | |
| 1984 | ||
| 1983 | Gary C. Holle '77 | Basketball/Baseball |
| 1982 | Joseph P. Healey '61 | Basketball |
| Stephen A. Walters '76 | Basketball | |
| Thomas F. Venter '71 | Golf | |
| 1981 | Rod Brooks '74 | Basketball |
| Mark Palinski '67 | Basketball | |
| Joseph B. Rukanshagiza '75 | Cross Country | |
| 1980 | Anthony Fabozzi '50 | Basketball |
| Charles F. Murphy, Jr. '68 | Golf | |
| Gerard V. Smith '62 | Basketball | |
| 1979 | Joseph R. Grasso '72 | Football |
| Joseph A. Gundermann, Jr. .'55 | Basketball | |
| John W. Rehfuss '42 | Basketball | |
| 1978 | Leo Callahan | Coach |
| Robert F. Hermann '70 | Basketball | |
| Frederick J. Shear '73 | Basketball | |
| 1977 | ||
| 1976 | David M. Holohan '61 | Lacrosse |
| William J. Kirsch '56 | Basketball | |
| Francis R. Koenig '56 | Basketball | |
| Joseph P. McCrudden '54 | Basketball/Baseball | |
| Louis W. Witt, Jr. '51 | Golf | |
| 1975 | John W. Obermayer '58 | Basketball |
| Thomas J. Pottenburgh '54 | Basketball | |
| Eric F. Bogdanowicz '49 | Baseball | |
| 1974 | ||
| 1973 | John F. Curry '54 | Basketball |
| Roy W. Peters, Jr. '51 | Basketball | |
| William J. Shields '49 | Golf | |
| John C. Weaver '59 | Basketball | |
| 1972 | Glenn A. Bissell '53 | Basketball |
| George A. Weber '48 | Basketball | |
| 1971 | Ralph F. Fedullo '52 | Basketball |
| Edmund F. Kolakowski '51 | Basketball | |
| Stanley Levine '43 | Sports Information Director | |
| John K. Mulvey, Jr. '65 | Basketball | |
| David R. Torncello, Jr. '51 | Basketball | |
| 1970 | Timothy Hill, Jr. '56 | Basketball |
| 1969 | William R. Hogan '53 | Basketball |
| 1968 | William J. Boland '50 | Basketball |
| George W. Bruda '50 | Basketball | |
| Rev. Maurus Fitzgerald | Athletic Director | |
| Charles Northrup '50 | Basketball | |
| 1967 | Daniel Cunha | Basketball (Coach) |
| 1966 | William Harrell '52 | Basketball |
| 1965 | Edward J. Lange, Jr. '50 | Basketball |
| 1964 | Howard T. Tucker '41 | Basketball |